"We believed, we persisted, we built it, we did it," board member Judy "Foodie" Carrino told the crowd at the West Chester Food Co-op's grand opening, as the Daily Local News reported on Oct. 7. The same story said it took 11 years to open.
What came out of those 11 years is a 2,800-square-foot store at 204 W. Market St., across from the Chester County Justice Center. It's open 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., seven days a week. For anyone who cooks with local food, the store changes the week. Until this fall, buying from local farms in the borough mostly meant a few hours on Saturday at Church and Chestnut. Now those Saturday hours have a store behind them the other six days. You'll see the difference first over Thanksgiving week, and much more clearly in January.
Eleven years for one downtown storefront
MyChesCo noted that downtown West Chester had gone decades without a traditional supermarket. It also reported that the co-op got here through years of fundraising, pop-up markets and development work. The store opened in late August. The ribbon cutting came at a grand opening attended by more than 100 owners and well-wishers. In the Daily Local's account, store team leader Issa Ostrander told the crowd, "When we started it was just an empty shell. This is your store, the community store." At the same event, Bridget Palombo of The Food Trust talked about a $75,000 grant from the Pennsylvania Fresh Food Financial Initiative.
The Daily Local described the store as the borough's first grocery in decades to sell mostly locally sourced milk, bread, meats and vegetables. The co-op defines "local" as producers within about 100 miles. It's member-owned, with 868 member-owners as of the Oct. 7 report, but anyone can shop there without joining.
The location matters too. The store sits next to a parking garage and the bus terminal, so you can walk, drive or take the bus. The market at Church and Chestnut is a short walk away.
The Saturday-only problem
The West Chester Growers Market is a producer-only market, which means the person selling you the bread or cheese is the one who made it. Its regular season runs May through December, every Saturday from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. That's four hours a week. If you missed the market on Saturday, buying from a local farm usually meant waiting until the next Saturday.
The co-op fills those other days. Its hours add up to 84 a week, compared with the market's four, and several producers now show up in both places.
Who's on the shelves, and who sells in both places
The co-op's vendor directory reads like a who's who of West Chester food makers. MyChesCo picked out these suppliers as the closest to the store:
- From West Chester itself: Unruly Nature, Sneaky Brew, Poppy Ski's Pierogi, Mindfully Mina's, Golden Valley Roasters and The Jawnery Bakery
- From elsewhere in Chester County: Vera Pasta, Bailys Dairy, Chaikhana Chai, Good Girl Bakery, Baba's Brew and Swarmbustin' Honey
- Produce: Bryn Clovis Farm in Malvern, about nine miles from the store, plus Paradise Organics and Lancaster Farm Fresh Cooperative from Lancaster County and Four Seasons Produce in Ephrata
The directory also lists Green Lion Breads, Merzbacher's Bakery, Rosenberger Dairy, Sugartown Smoked Specialties, Appleville Treats, Fishtown Pickle Project, Side Project Jerky and Black Cauldron Popcorn. The Daily Local's opening-week story also reported vegan, plant-based and gluten-free products on the shelves.
Some of those names will be familiar from Saturdays. Vera Pasta is on the Growers Market's regular vendor list. Mindfully Mina's appears on the market's rotating guest roster. Most of the market's lineup is still found only at the market, including Big Sky Bread, Amazing Acres Goat Dairy, Conebella Farm, North Star Orchard, Forgedale Fungi, Society of Bacon, Ridge Valley Maple and Fahnestock Fruit Farm. So the co-op doesn't replace the market. You can do the market on Saturday and pick up the rest at the co-op during the week.
Thanksgiving week shows how the two fit together
The first test is the week leading up to Nov. 26. The Growers Market has a Thanksgiving Market on Saturday, Nov. 21, from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. at Chestnut and Church, and its listing reminds shoppers to preorder turkeys. This year, here's what the rest of the week looks like after the market closes:
| Day | Where | Hours |
|---|---|---|
| Sat., Nov. 21 | Growers Market Thanksgiving Market, Church and Chestnut | 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. |
| Sat., Nov. 21 | West Chester Food Co-op, 204 W. Market St. | 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. |
| Sun., Nov. 22, through Wed., Nov. 25 | West Chester Food Co-op | 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily |
The co-op is open until 8 p.m. on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, the same as every other day, so you can still walk over for last-minute groceries that evening. For Thanksgiving Day hours, check westchester.coop.
January is the bigger handoff
Thanksgiving is the warm-up. The bigger change comes after New Year's, when the Growers Market switches to its winter season. From January through April it meets only on the first, third and fifth Saturdays of the month, from 10 a.m. to noon. That works out to two hours a session, and in most months only two sessions.
This winter the co-op is open seven days a week alongside that schedule. When it opened, the Daily Local reported Bryn Clovis Farm produce, Good Girl Bakery goods and Bailey's Dairy milk on its shelves. The Saturday market sessions keep the producers you can only buy from in person, and the co-op covers the weeks in between.
MyChesCo framed the store's real challenge plainly. Now that it's open, it has to keep its sales up, keep buying from local producers, and keep drawing both members and nonmembers. In September the store had one full-time and 11 part-time employees. The co-op's first winter is when it most clearly becomes the main local-food option downtown.
If you'd like to join, a member share costs $400 once. You can pay it as $25 a month, or as $100 down plus 12 monthly payments of $25, and the details are on the co-op's ownership page. Membership is optional.
The busy December days around 204 W. Market
The holiday calendar brings big crowds to the blocks around the co-op, and the details affect where you park and which streets are open.
- Small Business Weekend, Nov. 27 to 29. On-street parking downtown is free all three days. That doesn't include the garages or lots, and the co-op sits next to a garage. Carolers are out Friday from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. and Saturday from noon to 2 p.m. Santa arrives on the fire truck Saturday at 3 p.m.
- Christmas Parade, Friday, Dec. 4. The tree lighting starts at 6:30 p.m. on the Historic Courthouse steps facing High Street, and the parade follows at 7 p.m. It goes on rain or shine, with no rain date. This year's parade will feature America250. It's also First Friday, so shops will have special sales and stay open later.
- Christkindlmarkt, Saturday, Dec. 12. The seventh annual market runs from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. and is free, with more than 100 vendors. Gay Street between Darlington and Matlack and Church Street between Chestnut and Courthouse Alley are closed to cars all day. That Church Street stretch begins at the corner the Growers Market uses on Saturdays. West Market Street isn't on the closure list.
Over these weekends, the co-op is a good stop before or after the crowds, for whatever the holiday table still needs.
At Tallon & Olenik Team, we've watched the West Chester co-op go from pop-up markets to a real storefront, and we're glad to have it on West Market Street. If you're thinking about how a walkable grocery affects what your own West Chester home is worth, ask us for your free home valuation.